臺灣文學虛擬博物館

訊息
OK
Home/Literary Panorama/Reading Sexualities: The Many Faces of Gendered Literature in Taiwan/
The Lifting of Martial Law Was Followed by Widespread Gender Movements
Back

Reading Sexualities: The Many Faces of Gendered Literature in Taiwan

The Lifting of Martial Law Was Followed by Widespread Gender Movements

Women in Taiwan Counterattacked by WritingThe Literary World Worked Together with Society and the Legal WorldDiversity in Gender PoliticsBurgeoning Queer LiteratureGuide to Female Power

In 1979, the democratic beacon of the Formosa Incident led to widespread gender movements. In 1982, AWAKENING magazine was founded. In 1987, "Women's Rescue Foundation" was established. There were also social movements focused on rescuing child prostitutes and protecting the safety of women. As a result, gender movements spread and flourished.

Female writers who were active in the 1980s brought new attention to women's experiences and criticized the patriarchal social structure through their incisive writings. For instance Yuan Chiung-chiung's "A Place of One's Own" illustrates deep emotions; Liao Hui-yin's RAPESEED depicts a tragic woman's story; and Li Ang's THE BUTCHER'S WIFE launches an astounding attack.

Discussions of gender diversity also took place. Literature addressing sexual minorities was led by Pai Hsien-yung's CRYSTAL BOYS, with successors appearing one after another. Lin Yan's A THRUSH WHICH LOST ITS VOICE and Qiu Miao-jin's NOTES OF A CROCODILE, both of which tackle the subject of unaccepted love, triggered a heated debate in society regarding whether the problems described should be attributed to the protagonists or to society?


 


    Women in Taiwan Counterattacked by Writing

In the 1980s, female writers who grew up in Taiwan began to win literature awards given by the most prominent newspapers, creating a second wave of female writings in Taiwan. Their topics were no longer restricted to the living room or kitchen. They instead directly looked into the patriarchy, people at the bottom of the social ladder, and city life. They also boldly examined public and private matters such as extramarital affairs, relationships between women and their mothers-in-law, marital property, and wages. The awakened female writers at this time included Chiang Hsiao-yun, Su Wei-zhen, Hsiao Li-Hung, Hsiao Sa, Yuan Chiung-chiung, Chu Tien-hsin, Chu Tien-wen, and Ping Lu.
 

► XIA FEI'S HOME
Hsiao Sa's work in 1980. It won the United Daily News Literature Award for Best Mid-Length Novel. The book features a group of female protagonists moving from China to Taiwan and depicts how they become more mature and persistent despite their tumultuous life experience. The writer worked with director Chang Yi on the movie KUEI-MEI, A WOMAN in 1985, which won Golden Horse Awards for Best Adapted Screenplay and Best Director.
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)

 

► A THOUSAND MOONS ON A THOUSAND RIVERS
Hsiao Li-hung's work in 1980. It won the United Daily News Literature Award for Best Long Novel. The story is set in Budai, Chiayi in the 1970s. The town's gradual industrialization reflects the changes in society. The protagonist is a traditional Min woman. This work is a cultural contrast to XIA FEI'S HOME, which also won the award in the same year. Both stories feature similar predicaments.
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)

 

► Clipping of "What Do I do If My Husband Cheats on Me?"
From the 1980s, the literary supplement of each major newspaper regularly published women's writings and articles on female issues, attracting female writers to submit their works and open columns to join in the discussions. This clipping is an article written by Liao Hui-ying and published in INDEPENDENCE EVENING POST on April 14th, 1985. The article shows the changes in women's approaches to resolving marital problems. 
(Donated by Jiang Mu (Muye) / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

 

There were two eggs in my older brother's bowl. I only had one. The explanation Mother gave me regarding this difference was that my brother was a boy and he was still growing; he got an extra egg because he needed to eat more.

"Why can't I eat two eggs?" I murmured, "I threw away the chicken manure every evening. He has never cared for those chickens."

Mother was tongue-tied. After a while, she said: 'Don't dicker over this. Women are like rapeseeds; they grow where they are blown to by the wind. For an unmarried woman, it is not good enough even if she has the best life. I am treating you equally now. We don't have any money, but I still let you study, unlike other girls who are now working at factories. Your brother's going to be the one that continues the Li family in the future. Why are you quibbling about this? You don't even know what last name you're going to take in the future.'

──Liao Hui-ying, RAPESEED, 1982.

 Liao Hui-ying's RAPESEED depicts how women are like seeds blowing in the wind. They are not able to decide where they land and must accept whatever their destiny tells them. The female protagonist's mother has an unfortunate marriage, but still, she admonishes her daughter to accept her role. This novel criticizes the contraction of traditional women being both victims and perpetrators under a patriarchal system. This work was the first-prize winner in the 5th China Times Novel Award. It was made into a movie in 1984 and won Best Adapted Screenplay at the 21st Golden Horse Awards.


 


    The Literary World Worked Together with Society and the Legal World

In 1982, Lee Yuan-Chen founded AWAKENING magazine together with Liu Yu-hsiu and Yu Mei-nu. At the time, gender discrimination was still rife and the legal system still favored men. Gender pay gaps, unfair inheritance rules, and domestic violence were all injustices still permitted by society. Underpinned by feminist ideals, AWAKENING magazine fostered revolutionary ideals. Later in 1987, Cao Ai-lan and Shen Mei-zhen founded "Women's Rescue Foundation." Organizations from every corner of society joined forces to promote gender movements and legal reforms. For instance, a protest against child prostitution was held in 1988. Moreover, in 1990, Part IV of the civil law governing martial property was amended. The power of literature grew to a position that was on a par with that of social movements. The myriad voices calling for revolution came into sync and merged into an irrepressible trend.
 

 

🎬 I WANT TO WORK AND RAISE CHILDREN: A DOCUMENTARY ABOUT WORKPLACE PREGNANCY DISCRIMINATION  Director: Kuo Shiao-yun (1999)
To raise public awareness about the seriousness of pregnancy discrimination in practice, the Awakening Foundation entrusted Fullshot Foundation to shoot the documentary I WANT TO WORK AND RAISE CHILDREN. The film interviews many expectant mothers suffering from pregnancy discrimination and records their journeys of adaptation and resistance. At the time, Awakening Foundation went on a screening tour to various communities and unions, hoping to draw attention to self-awareness among female office workers and to reach a consensus on fighting for their basic rights. It also facilitated the enactment of Act of Gender Equality in Employment, which was passed in 2002 and implemented on Women's Day in the same year. (Source of the Video: Awakening Foundation)

 

  

► LITERATURE STAR, Issue 105
The 105th issue of LITERATURE STAR, published in March 1987. The person appearing on the cover is Alva Myrdal, the Nobel Peace Prize Winner. The issue introduces feminist ideas such as "Third Gender" and "Post-feminism." It also features Li Yuan Zheng's article about the reasons for her participation in the women's rights movement.
(Donated by Lin Zi-fen / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

► WOMEN'S POETRY
From 1995. Li Yuan Zheng is a poet and women's rights activist who has long been dedicated to the women's rights movement. The display is the cover of her WOMEN'S POETRY, which was published by Taipei County Cultural Center. 
(Donated by Li Kuei-hsien / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

  

► First issue of COMMOTION QUARTERLY
The first issue of COMMOTION QUARTERLY was published in June 1996 by Awakening Foundation. The publisher was Su Chien-Ling and the editor in chief was Hu Shu-wen. The introduction of the first issue puts emphasis on the magazine as a publication different from regular academic publications on women's and feminist studies. Instead, the magazine honed in on the real needs of women and on the goal of women's liberation. This premier issue contains discussions on new men and women's opinions about their country and its political scene. 
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)

 

► Clipping of "A Letter to My Ex-Husband"
"A Letter to My Ex-Husband," an article written by Hsiao Sa and published in the literary supplement of China Times on October 19th, 1986. 
(Donated by Jiang Mu (Muye) / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

► Clipping of "Goodbye 'My Love': Hsiao Sa Decides to Live for Herself"
He Sheng-fen's "Goodbye 'My Love': Hsiao Sa Decides to Live for Herself" was published in INDEPENDENCE EVENING POST on October, 1986.
(Donated by Jiang Mu (Muye) / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

 

It was rather difficult for Lin Shi to dodge Chen Jiang-shui. Lin Shi refused to moan like before, prompting Chen Jian-shui to sink in his fanatic and turbulent anger. Chen Jian-shui beat her, choked her, and squeezed her, prolonging the time he spent inside her. Lin Shi grit her teeth and endured it. She could only let out her breath through the gaps between her teeth. The wheezing sounds were like little animals breathing heavily before dying.

Sometimes when she couldn't bear it, she gave low-pitched groans. The sounds echoing in her mouth were sad and horrid.

Lin Shi had surely tried to resist before. No matter how Chen Jiang-shui abused her, there would always be a moment when he stopped to just swing his body on her. Once, Lin Shi grabbed the chance to push Chen Jiang Shui away when he was not paying attention. Yet when she rolled over and got off the bed, she realized there was nowhere to hide in the room

──Li Ang, THE BUTCHER'S WIFE, 1983.

 In 1982, Li Ang wrote THE BUTCHER'S WIFE, which is set in Lugang in the postwar period. The female protagonist, Lin Shi, has a rough life and is sold to butcher Chen as his wife. Yet, she is used as a low-status servant and a tool for satisfying Chen's sexual needs. Eventually, Lin Shi collapses emotionally and picks up the butcher's knife; she stabs Chen while he is asleep and dismembers the body.

This extremely controversial novel depicts a fictional story. However, a woman in Taiwan, Deng Ru-wen, killed her husband 11 years later after the publication of the novel. This incident unfolded in a manner uncannily close to the plot of the novel THE BUTCHER'S WIFE: Deng was forced to marry the businessman that raped her. After getting married, Deng, her family, and her children were abused and intimidated by her husband. As a result, she picked up a hammer and a fruit knife when he was drunk and killed him. Deng Ru-wen was given a sentence of jail time for manslaughter. Women's organizations later on called for attention to domestic violence and received an enormous response, leading to Taiwan passing Asia's first Domestic Violence Prevention Act in 1998.

 


► "Female Writers' Macroscopic and Microscopic Views on Society"
Li Ang published this article on the role of female writers and female issues in the literary world from the 1980s in the youth column of CHINESE FORUM JOURNAL. At the end of the article, the author claims to be a feminist instead of a women's rights activist. The article aims to examine the problems resulting from the role of women in modern society. 
(Donated by Jiang Mu (Muye) / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)


 


    Diversity in Gender Politics

Around the time that martial law was lifted in 1987, the government slightly loosened its grip on the people. As a result, the literary world began to boldly draw inspiration from current political issues. Several works interlacing personal lust and nationalistic allegories appeared. Chen Ye's MUD RIVER tells the tale of a big family in Tainan during the February 28 incident from a female perspective; Li Ang's "Bloody Sacrifice of The Makeup Face" touches upon two sensitive topics. The female protagonist's husband is a victim of the February 28 incident and her son is gay; Ping Lu's A LOVE STORY OF SUN YAT-SEN AND SOONG CHING-LING writes about Soong Ching-ling's personal life and overturns her vaunted image as "Mother of the Nation."

Magazines, theaters, and movies also joined this cultural experiment. In the 1990s, magazines such as GIRLFRIEND, THE EDGE OF THE ISLAND, and STIR, SISTERS, IN REVOLT provided channels to air opinions on gender equality and diversity. In 1994, Ho Chuen-juei chanted a shocking slogan in protest against sexual harassment, "Yes to Orgasms, No to Sexual Harassment!" This advocacy for sexual liberation and sex workers' rights forced later gender movements to pay attention to marginalized groups.

While social movements were making great strides, the literary world was thriving with works on women, homosexuality, the stigma of disease, and sexual minorities, which provided a platform for people in these communities to communicate with mainstream society.
 

► SILENT ISLAND
Su Wei-zhen's work published in 1994. It uses sex as the theme and tries to respond to emerging discussions on sex and sexual desire in society and the literary world. It won a Jury Recommendation in the first China Times Literature Awards. It was published by China Times Co. in the same year. 
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)


    

► THE EDGE OF THE ISLAND, Issue 14
THE EDGE OF THE ISLAND was founded in 1991 and was suspended in 1995 after releasing 14 issues. It was a very important magazine addressing issues of cultural theory in the 1990s. Just like the copy soliciting article submissions on the back cover, the magazine had almost no taboos. Common topics included gender, the body, and national identity. There were even discussions on queer issues in the beginning. This issue was the last issue. It is an advanced edition based on the theme of "Sexual Nation" in combination with topics on "Women's Land (False) Identity" from the 9th issue and "Queer" from the 10th issue. 
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)

 

 

"Mrs. Wang took out a mineral water spray from the bottom of her make-up box. She carefully sprayed a circle of water on the face of her son, who lay inside of a wooden coffin. Then, she took out the white creamy makeup remover, applied it evenly on her son's forehead, cheeks, and chin, and rubbed it gently

Without that pinkish foundation, his face immediately became gaunt. The deadly grey and whitish face already started to blacken, which showed an angry expression with grievances. Fortunately, his lips still had the crimson lipstick that was applied earlier. He looked eccentric, but at least a tinge of humanly color was kept.

Mrs. Wang hesitated a bit and did not remove the lipstick. She looked at her son's deadly grey face of grievances, and said softly in a comforting tone: "Don't worry, you don't have to fake anything anymore."

──Li Ang's "Bloody Sacrifice of The Makeup Face," BEIGANG INCENSE BURNER OF LUST, 1997.

 Li Ang's "Bloody Sacrifice of The Makeup Face" tells a tale of the family of a victim of the February 28 incident. The husband is taken away by military police in the middle of the night, leaving his pregnant wife behind. This wife, Mrs. Wang, a bridal makeup artist, later on actively participates in democracy movements. Yet, she has to painfully hide her son's homosexuality. Just like political secrets must be revealed in the end, Mrs. Wang finally makes peace with this fact following her son's death due to HIV, and puts feminine make-up on the face of her deceased son.


 


    Burgeoning Queer Literature

The literary atmosphere in the 1990s gushed with "end-of-the-millennia magnificence." There was a boom in the publication of gay literature. Lin Yan's A THRUSH WHICH LOST ITS VOICE was followed by Xu You-sheng's REWARD FOR ROMANCE, Chu Tien-wen's NOTES OF A DESOLATE MAN, Qiu Miao-jin's NOTES OF A CROCODILE, Chen Ke-hua's THE CONTROVERSIAL POEMS, Ji Da-wei's MEMBRANE, Chen Ying-Shu's HUMANS SHOULD NOT FLY, Chen Xue's BOOK OF WICKED WOMEN, Du Xiu-lan's UNFILIAL DAUGHTER, Wu Ji-wen's THE CHAOTIC GALAXY, and Tsao Li-chun's DANCE OF A MAIDEN. For ten years, the literary world continued to force society to examine various gender issues.

However, Taiwanese society was slow to accept new ideas. Gays suffered from HIV stigma and most lesbians chose not to reveal their sexual orientation. Unable to gain approval, some retreated into denial of their sexual identities, while some chose to end their lives.
 

  

► NOTES OF A DESOLATE MAN and Award
Chu Tien-wen's NOTES OF A DESOLATE MAN, a novel centered on the theme of homosexuality, was the first-prize winner of the first China Times Literature Awards in 1994. It was published by China Times Co. in the same year. 
(Donated by Chu Tien-wen / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

► TAIWAN LITERATURE, Issue 158
The 158th issue of Taiwan Literature (December 1996). This issue features multiple writers' works on older women and Chiu Kuei-fen's interview with Chen Xue. 
(Collection of the National Museum of Taiwan Literature)

 

  

► ALWAYS BE WITH YOU, a manga book
In 1997, Shen Lian-fang created the manga book ALWAYS BE WITH YOU published by Tong Li Publishing Co. This work was inspired by the suicide of two Taipei First Girls' High School students in Yilan. The book illustrates the event and the impact it had on society. Although one of the protagonists dies while the other survives to face harsh public criticism alone, the story ends positively. The book anticipates the state of Taiwan's LGBTQ community 20 years later. This book was the first manga centered on shoujo-ai (girls' love).

 

 

I used to believe that every man had a "dream woman" deep down in his heart throughout his life. His true love would be the woman that fit that type. Despite being a woman myself, I have a dream woman deep down in my heart. The woman of my dreams snuck into my reality and escaped like the most beautiful illusion arising from the fatal moment of being trapped in a frozen, towering mountain. I believed that she was the most perfect woman of my dreams and held on to this belief for four years. I spent my college years, when I was most courageous and honest, holding on to this belief

──Qiu Miao-jin, NOTES OF A CROCODILE, 1994.

 Qiu Miao-jin's NOTES OF A CROCODILE created a new set of vocabulary for queers. "Lazhi" became the secret code referring to lesbians. Qiu studied in Paris when she was 25 and committed suicide the following year, leaving behind a novel called LAST WORDS FROM MONTMARTRE. Her works contain vivid metaphors. "Bunnies" and "crocodiles" were used to symbolize the unspeakable suppression suffered by lesbians.

 

► Reaction to CONFESSIONS OF A MASK
Notes from Qiu Miao-jin after she read Yukio Mishima's Confessions of a Mask. Her response shows her attention to the human aspects of the characters, their spiritual lives, sorrows of humans and the meaning of death. Her writing shows her deep impression of the unique story and aesthetics of the book. CONFESSIONS OF A MASK, a partly autobiographical book, was Yukio Mishima's second long novel. The book is set in Japan during the chaotic social situation following the Second World War and boldly deals with homosexuality. The book caused quite a stir in the literary world at the time.
(Donated by Qiu Rui-qi / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 



 


∞ Guide to Female Power ∞

It is difficult to be a human. The things we find difficult are not the setbacks or stress, as people often think. Instead, the nature of existing in this society does not suit us. We find it difficult to live day by day, and often fall into an uncontrollable state of self-loathing

── "Suicides of Two TFG Students: Lin Chin-hui's Suicide Note," 1994.

 


Suicides of Lin Chin-hui and Shi Chi-ya

In 1994, two teenage girls, Lin Chin-hui and Shi Chi-ya, went together to a hotel in Su'ao and took their own lives by burning charcoal in their room. They were 17 years old and students at Taipei First Girls High School. Their suicide notes made the press suspect that they were a couple. However, this speculation was refuted by their families and the school. Based on this incident, singer Chuang Tzu-i and Two Fish wrote the song, "Them," and Shen Liang-fan created the first girls' love manga, ALWAYS BE WITH YOU.

◇     ◇     ◇


Igniting The Flame of Women's Rights: Death of Peng Wan-Run

On November 30th, 1996, Peng Wan-Run went to attend the National Representative Assembly in Kaohsiung as Director of the Women's Department of the Democratic Progressive Party. In the morning, she strived to lobby for a bill aimed at securing at least 25% female participation in politics. When the assembly ended, she took a taxi back to her hotel and then completely vanished. The police conducted an investigation and found that she was murdered. Her naked body was found disposed in the middle of nowhere. Women's rights organizations mournfully initiated a protest for women's rights. The Democratic Progressive Party also passed the provision guaranteeing women's participation in politics. The Legislative Yuan also swiftly passed Sexual Assault Crime Prevention Act in the beginning of 1997.

◇     ◇     ◇


Gender Landscape: Fembooks and GinGin Store

In 1994, Li Yuan-zheng and Zheng Zhi-hui founded Fembooks in Gongguan, Taipei. It was Taiwan's first bookstore dedicated to feminism. The name "Nüshu" (female books) came from a term used among women in Hunan, China meaning "exchanging secret emotions with one another", symbolizing the bookstore's dedication to women's writings, readings, and conversations. After decades in operation, it has become a landmark of the women's rights movements in Taiwan.

Five years following the establishment of Fembooks, GinGin Store was founded. It was Taiwan's first bookstore dedicated to gender diversity. The bookstore once had its windows smashed and was accused of indecency. However, its long-term promotion of Taiwan Pride and its fight for LGBT rights have made it a symbolic landmark.

 

  

 TAIWAN LITERATURE, Issue 145 (Issue 5, New Version)
This issue is the "women's literature special edition," published in 1994. Featuring poems, prose, novels, and critiques, it introduces the roles of housewives, women participating in politics, and works of photography and filmmaking from various perspectives. The magazine also discusses works like A THRUSH WHICH LOST ITS VOICE, Fembooks, and the seminar on "Love and Lust among Civilian Women." 
(Donated by Wu Yong Fu Foundation / From the National Museum of Taiwan Literature permanent collection)

 

Previous
The Beginning of the Women's Rights Movement under Authoritarian Rule
Next
Eternal Summer: Awareness of Sexuality Spreads Like Wildfire
Next
Conclusion & Chronology
Image shows
Source: